Hot water system failure: evidence for a solicitor's claim

Instructed by: a quantity surveyor acting for the owner's solicitors
Location: confidential
Property: high-value private residence

A high-value private residence, finished in the mid-2000s, started leaking from its hot water system soon after handover. Leaks appeared in several upper-floor rooms, behind expensive finishes, and the house couldn't be used as intended.

The owner's solicitors needed to know why, and who was responsible.

The question

My role

I was instructed through a quantity surveyor acting for the solicitors. My job was to establish the cause independently, and set out the evidence clearly enough to support a claim.

What I did

  • Reviewed the as-built drawings, construction records, earlier reports and the photographic record.

  • Inspected the accessible voids and the leak locations on site.

  • Set the evidence out on CAD drawings, tying each leak to the pipework involved.

  • Pipework samples were laboratory tested, the manufacturers were consulted on whether their materials were suitable, and mechanical engineers assessed the boilers, valves and controls.

  • The hot water pipework was made from material that wasn't suitable for hot water.

  • The system ran beyond its design limits.

  • The installation didn't meet the required standards.

  • The boilers lacked essential safety cut-offs and controls.

The leaks weren't bad luck or one-off failures. They came from the choice of material and the way the system was installed and controlled. With pipework concealed throughout the house, more leaks were likely.

What I found

The solicitors had independent, tested evidence of the cause. The owner had a step-by-step plan to replace the system with suitable materials while protecting the finishes.

The result

When the stakes are high and the parties disagree, an opinion isn't enough. This case rested on laboratory results, manufacturer evidence and the record, not on what anyone assumed.

Why it matters

Previous
Previous

The Elms Centre, Banbury, Oxfordshire

Next
Next

Leak blamed for a wet floor: the cause was underneath